Thicker than cold peanut butter
Tiffany Doll is a butter lover 6: the Anal Squat Challenge helps her finally push out the lost butter stick
Bread and butter Me up
Abella Danger is a butter lover part 10: her butthole is addicted to anal butter lube, she can't get enough!
Like butter
Romi Rain is a butter lover part 1: her asshole is so tight that it can't take the whole butter stick at first
Leya Falcon is a butter lover part 4: rubbing the anal butter all over her body, "I feel like such a dirty whore!"
Cici and Sarah's anal butter threesome part 2: Cici gets her rectum filled to the brim with butter and cock
Penis Butter And Jelly
Leya Falcon is a butter lover part 10: so horny from the butter, she stuffs her thong panties up her ass too!
Romi Rain is a butter lover part 7: stretching her sphincter open with a speculum to retrieve the butter
Tiffany Doll is a butter lover 3: squatting on Mike's cock so he can push the butter deep inside her rectum
Jynx's anal 3-course meal 9: her hungry gluttonous asshole swallows a whole stick of butter with ease
Alyssa Cole gets a cold stick of butter up her asshole
Leya Falcon is a butter lover part 9: her hungry asshole swallows even more butter, she just can't get enough
Abella Danger is a butter lover part 7: she does a few anal squats with butter splattered all over her ass
Butter
Mike churns butter inside Ella's asshole and rectum (part 2 in comments)